Cage: Heavy Rain not possible on Xbox 360

  • Posted May 15th, 2009 at 16:32 EDT by Mike Harradence
  • 24,626 views
  • 59 Comments

Quantic Dreams’ David Cage has declared that PlayStation 3 exclusive thriller Heavy Rain would be “too difficult” to replicate on Xbox 360.

Speaking to NowGamer, Cage explained, “I think this game can only be done on PlayStation 3,” adding, “We used all the SPUs, [and] I think to do the visuals, and all the stuff we’re doing would be too difficult [on the 360].”

Apparently, the game’s elaborate physics and crowd-related shenanigans are too much for Microsoft’s white box to handle, said Cage. “There are amazing physics there, and stuff with crowds that you just couldn’t really get.”

Can’t say we’re all that surprised, given that Heavy Rain is one of the PS3’s technical highlights for the 2009 line-up. The game’s out later this year.

Advertisement

Comments

Comment

What are your thoughts?

  1. The Praiseworthy | The-Praiseworthy

    • 4:36pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    They would need two 360s to run Heavy Rain :)

  2. SergeantR7

    • 4:38pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    More proof that PS3 is the way to go. XD

  3. Sufi

    • 4:39pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    *cough* *cough* *silence*

  4. FloodOne | FloodOne

    • 4:43pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    who cares what it looks like, if it plays like shiiiii.....

  5. Trustter | trustter

    • 5:01pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    We all knew about it. This is so old.

    Next please.

  6. coverton341 | groovy341

    • 5:02pm BST - May 15th, 2009

     Hopefully it is as spectacularly awesome as I can see the hype train making it out to be

  7. taurus82 | taurus82

    • 5:11pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Much like the classic point n'click adventures gameplay has never been the selling point, so if Heavy Rain is the evolution of this genre then the gameplay won't matter.

  8. Perishing_Mind

    • 5:13pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    That is because Sony obviously have the rights for this game, and also it's plain PR-Talk. Gears of War is also not possible on PS3...just a matter of publishing rights.

  9. FPSgamer | niminum239

    • 5:15pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    The amazing visuals look stunningly realistic. This is probably the 1st game that looks very authentic to me.

  10. darzero

    • 5:18pm BST - May 15th, 2009

     Expect to see more games on ps3 not possible on xbox as all the dev are finally understanding the architecture of the ps3.

     

    ho, and perishing mind; Gears is so possible on ps3, that would actually make it better.

  11. Solrac | Solrac7688

    • 5:33pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    @10 everyone knows that Gears would look better on the PS3 but what #8 is getting at is the fact that if Microsoft has rights to this game then it wouldn't be possible on the PS3. PAY ATTENTION

  12. Brokentusk81

    • 5:38pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    When are we ever going to see a game that comes out on both consoles, but looks crappy on the xbox360??? I want proof instead of all this "here is an exclusive which is only coming out for PS3 anyway, but if it werent we couldnt do it " bullcrap.

  13. mcav | mcav

    • 5:56pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Well, yeah... obviously.

     

    Anyone who isn't quite sure how much more powerful the PS3 is over the 360, please consider this.

     

    Wipeout HD and Burnout Paradise have both run in full 3D on the PS3.  That means a doubling of the refresh rate and essentially rendering the entire game twice.

     

    In my opinion, the PS3 is sooooo being sandbagged right now.

     

     

  14. markwesker

    • 5:58pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    poor 360 just cant seem to be able to handle a powerfull game,maybe microsoft should jack in the 360 n stick to software.

  15. x_HAWX_x

    • 6:02pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Who cares man , we all knoe Ps 3 owns anyday !

  16. Silent_Killer

    • 6:18pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    # 12 the reason that the PS3 is crapier in multiplatform games is that the companies try to make the game the same for both consoles. The ps3 is better so they are making the game that he will fit 360 (because its crapier) and then the result is that they worked on the game more on the 360 and less on the ps3...you can see the difference between the exlusives KZ2 - GOW2    HEAVY RAIN beats everything in graphics...so there is your answer....by the way wait for FINEL FANTESY XIII...YOU WILL SEE THE DIFFERECE THERE!!!!

  17. iplayonlysony

    • 6:25pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    When is this game coming out again.  I wanted it to come out this summer.

  18. Tetsu | Tetsumura

    • 6:33pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Eutechnyx takes the Forza 2 engine, ports it to the PS3 and suddenly they can get 16 cars on track.  The "easier" system has been out 3 years now, so where are the huge games with a zillion things on screen?

  19. arfi-gorgona-O

    • 6:35pm BST - May 15th, 2009

     cool i want this game im all for that kind of games.

  20. rycexboi

    • 6:42pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Hopefully when this game comes outs..everyone can **** about 360 and ps3 being equal.

  21. RagingStorm | RagingStormX

    • 6:47pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Shouldn't this be an article to post on a 360 site....letting them know why they are not getting the game?

  22. DeanoIV | MaterialBoy

    • 6:47pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    I have a bad feeling that this game won't make it out this year. We never hear anything about it or see anything new. I bet 2010.

  23. KZ3000

    • 7:20pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Well its gonna be an PS3 exclusive anyway.right?

    i smell something fishy...

  24. Overcast | Gamenificent

    • 7:36pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    I'm not a tech whiz but I called this one right the first time I saw it in motion. Nerd Points!!!

  25. mortada

    • 7:37pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    i have to say that such news are music to my ears,but i really hope that the difference between the the ps3 and the ex-box is displayed directly through one game that utilizes the full potential of both platforms like what is said to be true for FFX111

  26. eysmond

    • 7:49pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    PS3 FTW :D

    If gameplay and story will be similar or i hope better from Fahrenheit it will be perfect game for me.

  27. Grim_Dicer

    • 7:51pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    meh ... bet the game is rubbish when it arrives. Great visuals, maybe bad gameplay

  28. jimmy303

    • 7:52pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    i´v heard that before

  29. tgf5 | tgf5

    • 8:55pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Where are all the 360 owners now to defend this? LOL

  30. GrugNorg0606 | L1QU1D_F0X (The I's are ones & the O is a zero)

    • 9:14pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    I can't wait! Also excited for omikron 2 if anyone remembers that game.

  31. SuperSaiyan5555

    • 9:38pm BST - May 15th, 2009

     Comments like this makes me wonder, if a game like Heavy Rain is impossible on 360, how are they gna port over MGS4! the rumors are circling around at the minute about MGS4+Oxide and as much as i don't want to believe it, i think there is a distinct possibility that it could be true, but when David Cage says this it just makes me confused to the whole situation, i don't want MGS4 to go to 360, they'll ruin it!!! 

  32. Drak_Shadowreap

    • 9:55pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    @ 31

    Hahaha, don't believe the lies, there will never be a MGS4 360 port, I'd bet my life on it anyday.

  33. Brokentusk81

    • 10:13pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    @16 I don't know about that explanation, cause it would work in reverse too. And periodicals like gameinformer almost always give the edge to xbox360 versions. Plus, i used to play rainbow six on the PS2, and my brother's xbox version was a 1000 times better. SO your argument doesn't convince me. I want side by side proof.

  34. Overcast | Gamenificent

    • 11:08pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    @33 you do understand that from a technical point the xbox is more powerful than the PS2, right? That example doesn't make sense. Certain games run better on certain systems because of the developers and tech involved individually across projects. Think about the people who botched the Orange Box port for the PS3, do you think it's impossible for the PS3 to run that properly? I used to have Oblivion on 360 before it RRODed on me and now I have it on PS3 and the game runs way better. Just depends on what individual game you are talking about.

    I'm sure there are games on PS3 that won't run properly on the 360, form a technical standpoint the PS3 is more powerful than the 360 and thereby has the potential to accomplish more, it really depends on how well (and much) each developer utilizes the tools.

  35. Brokentusk81

    • 11:39pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    Tru dat.  And yes of course I understand the hardware difference between PS2 and xbox.


  36. Centurion-Legion777 | Centurion-Legion

    • 11:40pm BST - May 15th, 2009

    people say that graphics and phsycis dont matter as long as you have good gameplay, well actually... NO. i dont want a play a game with great gameplay and ps1 graphics. its about the both.

    generally every game with good graphics has good gameplay (not that one has to do anything with the other)

  37. ptmww3

    • 11:04am BST - May 16th, 2009

    Raining heavly on white cage lol. I am sorry MS no one can go against SONY

  38. xVxSMOKExVx

    • 5:18pm BST - May 16th, 2009

    @12 They have found that when the multi plat is lead on 360 it does not port well to the ps3, but when lead on ps3, or made seperately on both consoles things port smoothly.  Sometimes even better on ps3.  For example Devil May Cry 4, and Burnout Paradise, Call of Duty 4.  Now exclusives are obviously not possible on 360 due to the fact PS3 has the cell, and 1st party devs utilize the cell (unlike 3rd party multi plat games).  They have not even scratched the surface of the cell broadband engine from what I understand.  Anyways 3rd party is just perks now a days what matters are your exclusives, and Sony wins that battle everytime.

    I am excited for this game, but right now I have my sights on Uncharted 2, God of War 3, and Gran Turismo 5.  I love Sony.

  39. Gunbladewarrior | Gunbladewarrior2

    • 8:50pm BST - May 16th, 2009

    Someone show me where it says that M$ owns the rights to Gears? I could've sworn Epic is the one that owns it.-_-

  40. AntFarm

    • 9:05am BST - May 17th, 2009

    i dont need proof to know the ps3 is stronger then xbox 360. Only the 360 fanboys that keep denying it. And what about this game? how does it play? like a movie, nothing but quick time events? I wanna be able to control my character, not push a button and have it animated for me. Let me tell you some good games im looking foward too.

    Uncharted 2

    God of War 3

    inFamous

    Rachet&Clank

    ...

  41. A-HAAA

    • 5:37pm BST - May 17th, 2009

    this trend is going to continue as the years go by the 360 just isnt powerful w=enough to keep up with the nest gen games

  42. cecil2oo8

    • 5:32am BST - May 19th, 2009

    dont` cry Bill , Xp

  43. on1om

    • 5:29am GMT - December 2nd, 2009

    This dissapoints me, but still. Can't people just stop whining about which is better.

    Everyones gonna have a different idea which one is better and why.

    For me, it's that the 360 is cheaper than the PS3, And I like the controller better for the 360. But on the PS3 I look forward to only a few exclusives that aren't even out yet, like The Last Guardian or this. I don't really give a damn about graphics, I still play ancient games like Doom, Deus Ex or Wolfenstein, If I showed one of those games to one of my friends, they'd be like "how can you play that, it's crap". But to me it's not, because I don't care about graphics :0 And my opinion is different. :000

  44. Forza3NowNotGT5Later

    • 6:05am GMT - January 21st, 2010

    Promising premise, and at last a good reason to consider a discounted PS3. But gotta say the facial characteristics in the trailer are awful. If that's convincing to you you must have a weird looking family. Also quite amusing that every dual console release the xbox version gets the nod for graphics and gameplay. The Archimedes computer was far more powerful than the 64/Amiga but developers will go to the better implemented platform and consumers will go for the price, the titles, the community and the

  45. al1988

    • 3:59pm GMT - February 10th, 2010

    if you check the gamesspot's playstation vs xbox graphichs comparisons you will see that in almost every one xbox graphics are more detailed, better, cleaner and commented negativly for playstation. so dont say that xbox cant handle this and this is all publishing matters. like grand turismo

  46. kuehnau

    • 11:52pm GMT - February 12th, 2010

    just another BS response from developers trying to make the PS3 look better then it is. If they had really wanted Heavy Rain to be on the Xbox 360, then they would have had it developed multi-platform. That simple, case closed. Looks like there is going to be another PS3 title I won\'t be missing.

  47. hghghghg

    • 4:58am GMT - February 13th, 2010

    xbox 360's better. PS3 sucks. Sorry Sony....you suck balls.

  48. smithy93

    • 11:36pm GMT - February 24th, 2010

    i know that it isnt goin to be on the xbox 360, but it looks like the best game to come out for quite a while, and it's a shame that it's not goin to be played on the 360. PLEASE BRING MORE GAMES OUT LIKE THIS BUT FOR THE XBOX 360 PLEASE

  49. ikilledyou123

    • 6:01pm GMT - February 26th, 2010

    I WANT IT ON 360 NOWW PLEASEE BILL GATES IS A stupidi imbvosile  AND Y CANT THE XBOX AND PS3 JUST WORK TOGETHER WHY U ASK THTS BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT WORRIED ABOUT PEOPLE WHO BUY THERE GAMES OHH NO ITS JUST ABOUT THE god damn MONEY ALWAYS ABOUT THE MONEY MONEY IS NOT NOTHING ITS JUST A BIT OF PAPER SAYING 10 ON IT

  50. TheOldSchoolGamer

    • 11:14pm GMT - February 26th, 2010

    I f it weren't for the fanboys giving their worthless two cents i'd whole heartedly agree that the ps3 is a fine machine, much better then the 360 in a lot of ways. But i love my 360, and it makes me mad that exclusives like little big planet and heavy rain cant find their way to the 360. also we shared one our exclusives with you guys, BIOSHOCK.. yea. its like that. I dont give 1/10th of a flying Funk about graphics. I would play the most pixelated piece of crud with glee, listening to you pretentious ps3 owners makes me sick. Play for fun or sit the heck down.

     

Related information

  • Related game: Heavy Rain

    Release date (US):
    February 23rd, 2010
    Developer:
    Quantic Dream
    Genre:
    Action - Interactive Drama
    Rank:
    18 of 1,515 Games
    Up 0 places (in last 7 days)

Related videos

Related images

All trophies for this game

More

eXTReMe Tracker