NHL 2K9 Review
- Posted September 23rd, 2008 at 13:00 EDT by
- 5 Comments
- PSU Review Score
- Avg. user review score:
You must be logged in to rate a game
NHL 2K9 will appeal to longtime fans of the series, though gamers looking for a more realistic experience are likely to jump ship to NHL 09 for this season.
- Variety of deke maneuvers
- Bearded playoffs
- Team-Up online mode
- Game speed is too fast
- Poor AI system
- Somewhat too arcade-like
It feels like only yesterday that I was playing 2K Hockey on the Dreamcast and reveling in the fact that it was superior to the competition in every facet. Fast-forward seven years and NHL2K has taken a backseat to the competition in terms of realism and authenticity. For the past four months, 2K has run a marketing campaign promoting the slogan, “Bringing the fun back to hockey.” Of course, this begs the question, has 2K acccompished such a feat? Read on to find out.
Naturally, the most important aspect of any sports title is how the game plays in comparison to its real-life counterpart. Unfortunately, those looking for an authentic experience are going to be disappointed here, as NHL 2K9 deviates from form and offers up a noticeably faster paced game of hockey than what you'd usually expect. On top of the slight speed increase, skaters are equipped with a speed burst that takes it a little over the top when comparing it to other hockey titles. This abundance of speed allows for breakaways to spring out far too frequently, which often results in easy goals. While I understand how fun it might be to make the light and horn go blaring, it simply becomes almost too frequent to enjoy. As such, many players may feel like scoring a goal is less of an achievement and more of an expected occurrence.
However, regardless of these issues, the game’s major flaw is the artificial intelligence. Ultimately, the AI within NHL 2K9 is highly inferior compared to past iterations, and as a result was one of the things that left me extremely unsatisfied. Yet, as disappointing as this is, it doesn’t completely deter from the overall experience; essentially, the game is still very enjoyable so long as it’s the type of hockey you’re looking to play. 2K9 is very comparable to GRID from Codemasters. As many of you know, GRID walks the thin line of both a racing simulator and arcade racer, which is exactly the same thing NHL 2K9 is offering gamers. While there are going to be situations where you’re going to have to set up a play in order to score a goal like you should, there's also going to be strings of games where all you need to do is wind up a couple of one-timers while crashing the next which ends up in you destroying the competition. Yes, hockey relies a lot on the philosophy of just getting the puck on the net, but 2K9 seems to have too many occurrences where the puck goes in, as though the goalie AI isn’t fast enough to keep up.
Fortunately 2K Sports still allows you to take part in the standard modes of play such as Franchise, Exhibition, and Online, though this year they’ve also implemented a lot of cool mini-games to change up the pace a tad. Gamers can lace up their skates for some 3-on-3 action on a mini-rink, take it out to the pond for some outdoor competition or drive the Zamboni around in between periods. While none of these will keep your attention for long, they’re a somewhat enjoyable, yet brief distraction all the same.
As for how the game handles, you can expect a much tighter feel than in the past. 2K has thrown out the complex control scheme for three styles of play that will appeal to a larger audience than before. There are basic controls for those who are new to the franchise, Pro Stick Evolution for those who enjoy the same controls as EA’s NHL product and finally a Hybrid mixture of both formats. Regardless of which you choose, 2K has also implemented some neat 1-on-1 deke controls for you to take advantage of. While holding down L1, you can utilize the right analog for your skates and the left analog for your stick. Therefore you can press the two in different directions in order to perform several different maneuvers. Of course, some work better than others, but nothing feels better than showing your friends up on your way to glory. Furthermore, nothing compliments your actions better than Randy Hahn and Drew Remenda, who both do a stellar job announcing the play-by-play action on the ice.
Much like NHL 09, 2K has chosen the online component ... (continued on next page)
- Page 1
- Page 2
- 8:34am EDT - September 23rd, 2008
I REALLY did not like this game compared to NHL 09
- 8:36am EDT - September 23rd, 2008
i hear NHL 09 is the defacto standard this year anyways, why defect to a substandard?
- 12:49pm EDT - September 23rd, 2008
No such thing as too fast man....
- 1:22pm EDT - September 23rd, 2008
this game is huge piece of crap compared to nhl 09 gameplay wise. i played the demo for both and easily chose nhl 09. 2k9 is just not as good graphically or in the controls. i know own 09 and i love it.
- 4:22pm EDT - September 23rd, 2008
ever since '07, easports destroyed this battle hands down.
This will permanently ban this user and delete all associated comments. This action is irreversible, are you SURE you want to do this?!