PDA

View Full Version : Rock Band 2 REVIEW THREAD - first review is UP!!



Nuvian
09-14-2008, 09:52
OUR RATING: 9.3
EXCELLENT

TANGIBLES:
Gameplay:http://images.ampednews.com/news/ui_xbox_pixel.gif9
Visuals:http://images.ampednews.com/news/ui_xbox_pixel.gif7
Audio:http://images.ampednews.com/news/ui_xbox_pixel.gif10
Value:http://images.ampednews.com/news/ui_xbox_pixel.gif10
Quality:http://images.ampednews.com/news/ui_xbox_pixel.gif10

Why you should buy it: If you were a fan of the first game, this is a no brainer. There's enough new content and modes to be worth the money.
Why you should rent it: If you've never played Rock Band, this is a very good starting place.


http://images.ampednews.com/news/ui_news_ec2.gif

When Rock Band’s price of $170 was announced in the middle of last year, many people wondered whether anyone would be willing to put up that kind of money up front for a game. With a consistent spot on the top sales charts, the answer was apparently yes. Why did Rock Band do so well? It’s simple really; music brings people together, and Rock Band is a game all about forming a band and making music. It had all the elements in place to be a huge hit and it turned out to be just that. Since the game’s release though, maybe fans have been giving feedback on what could have made the game even better. We’re roughly a year from the release of the original, and most of these requests have been taken to heart in Rock Band 2.


http://images.ampednews.com/news/screenshots/2389/15/t_46411.jpg (http://javascript<b></b>:screen('/screenshot.php?image=49836'))
What you get in Rock Band 2 is a more refined and streamlined experience. This is most noticeable in the game’s brand new menu system. There is no more Solo or Multiplayer menu. Now you simply select what mode you want to play and populate your band with either people in the same room or across the country over Xbox Live. If that were all that had been changed in Rock Band 2 it would be very hard to recommend shelling out another $60 for it, but thankfully, that’s only scratching the surface.

One of the most requested features from fans of the original game was the ability to play the game’s Band World Tour mode online. This is now possible with Rock Band 2 and it works very well. Another request along the same lines was the ability to play the World Tour mode in Single Player mode. Harmonix has listened to the fans and now the Tour mode is now the main Career mode for both Solo and Multiplayer. The old linear career mode for each instrument has been done away with.

The way the main Tour mode works has also been tweaked a bit. You’ll still be going from city to city and venue to venue acquiring fans and scoring Tour Stars, but there will now be some random events that will pop up which will give you various rewards like double the money or quadruple the fans for meeting a specific condition. You’re still playing music, but these random events do keep things interesting.


http://images.ampednews.com/news/screenshots/2389/15/t_48422.jpg (http://javascript<b></b>:screen('/screenshot.php?image=52099'))
You can now also hire Staff members to help your band out. This is an aspect of the Tour that could have possibly been done a bit better. The Staff act effectively as bonuses, giving you boosts or penalties depending on whether you succeed at a song or fail it. You can only have one hired Staffer at a time, so you’ll mostly likely end up just picking one and staying with them. A band needs a team of people to keep things working smoothly, and a bit more refining on this element might’ve made it something a bit more worthwhile. It doesn’t hurt the game for being there, but it certainly could have been a lot more.

The Tour mode also has a Challenge sub-mode. This is similar to the game’s old Career mode where you play several songs and then move onto the next set. This time though, there are multiple events in each Challenge Tier and some of them require a full band to play. It doesn’t matter what instrument you play or how many people you have around there will always be something to do in the Tour mode.

http://images.ampednews.com/news/screenshots/2389/15/t_46414.jpg (http://javascript<b></b>:screen('/screenshot.php?image=49839'))
Making its debut this year is the new Battle of the Bands mode. This mode is similar to the Challenge mode, but there are specific conditions that must be met. Some challenges have you going for the longest note streak, some for the highest score, etc. This mode is dynamic, meaning that Harmonix will be releasing new Battle of the Bands challenges on a regular basis, so there should always be something available for you to shoot for.

Training mode has received a bit of tuning as well this year. You’ll find that your combo streak is counted this time around, so if you’re practicing tricky sections you’ll have a better idea of whether you’re getting better at it or not. The biggest addition to the Training mode is the new Drum Trainer. This mode gives you the chance to brush up on your drum technique, as well as showing you how to put together a proper drum fill. Drummers looking to improve should definitely spend some time here. Now if they’d only do the same thing for Guitar, Bass, and Vocals.

Rock Band’s gameplay was just about flawless to begin with, but Harmonix has done a bit of tinkering under the hood to make things better overall. Hammer-ons and Pull-offs have been tuned a bit. The timing is ever so slightly looser, meaning that tricky Guitar and Bass parts are a tad easier now. They’ve also added the ability to Hammer-on and Pull-off Chords which was never possible before. You’ll appreciate this on songs with very quick chord transitions. For drummers not a lot has changed, though some songs now have Drum Solos which was another oft requested feature. Vocals haven’t had much done to them in terms of things you can see up front, but the game does seem to be a bit better at picking up on some of the talky parts of certain songs.

Visually Rock Band 2 hasn’t changed that much. The stage animations of your band mates were already good, and this has improved a bit, especially when it comes to the Vocalist’s moves. Other than the new UI and a few interesting stage effects not much has changed. It wasn’t bad to begin with, so there really wasn’t much reason for them to mess with what worked.

http://images.ampednews.com/news/screenshots/2389/15/t_46414.jpg (http://javascript<b></b>:screen('/screenshot.php?image=49839'))
What made Rock Band great was its music and sound. Rock Band had a total of 58 songs on the disc. Rock Band 2 comes with 84 tracks ranging in genre from Classic Rock to Black Metal. Each track is a master recording; there are no covers this time around. There really is a lot on here, bands range from Kansas and The Steve Miller Band to Metallica and Dream Theater. There will most likely be something that you’ll like on the game’s soundtrack. Even better than that though, all of the money that you’ve spent on Rock Band DLC isn’t lost, since all of that content carries over automatically. You can also export 55 of the 58 songs from the original Rock Band disc. Harmonix is also offering 20 free bonus songs to people who buy Rock Band 2, so this game has the potential to have the largest library of songs of any music game.

Rock Band 2 is a solid sequel. Harmonix smoothed out most of the rough edges and added enough new stuff to warrant the full priced upgrade. Online World Tour mode may be enough for some people to spend the $60, but you’ll also get a whole new suite of songs and a few new modes to have fun in. If you were on the fence about getting Rock Band 2, rest assured that it is indeed worth the money.

Source (http://www.gamer20.com/gamehub/rock-band-2-x360/review/1361/1)
I still haven't decided if i'm getting a music game or which one.

Thorzilla
09-14-2008, 10:13
Nuv, get Rock Band. It's twice as good as GH. The interface looks cleaner and better. Songs are better charted in my opinion.

Here's IGNs review:


9.5 Presentation
Superb execution, with perfect camera cuts on stage and plenty of your band's personality shining through.
8.0 Graphics
It looks almost identical graphically, which is fine, since last year's model was pretty enough to get the job done.
9.5 Sound
A stellar soundtrack that is, without question, the greatest assemblage of songs to date for a videogame.
9.0 Gameplay
Little has changed in terms of how the game plays, but there have been some very welcome additions. Battle of the Bands is inspired. World Tour, though, needs a revamp.
10 Lasting Appeal
There's still a hefty amount of time to waste on World Tour, but it's the dynamic Player Challenges and Battle of the Bands that will have you hooked for the next year.
9.0
Outstanding OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)

Can't wait for this. The 1st was brilliant!

the_End
09-14-2008, 13:50
Rock Band 2 for the ************* win!!!!! Can't wait to pick this up on my PS3. Oh and this is for Thor:

Painkiller - Full Band - 5*

This tops that Screaming for Vengeance video you posted. Skip to the 2 minute mark, they start off with the free song that was up last week. Painkiller>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Anything on GH:WT track list.

Evoking1230
09-14-2008, 15:06
sweet!

definitely purchasing it for my PS3

ManaBurnX
09-14-2008, 15:38
I'm not getting the set but I do plan on getting the game. I wonder if the game alone will still have the 20 bonus dlc songs for free.

the_End
09-14-2008, 17:04
I'm not getting the set but I do plan on getting the game. I wonder if the game alone will still have the 20 bonus dlc songs for free.

The hell? There going to be DLC released at a later date so of course they will.

ManaBurnX
09-14-2008, 17:13
No, I don't mean the normal dlc. If you get Rockband 2 they will give you a special code inside on the back of the manual that will let you download 20 dlc songs for free. I'm just wondering if it will also be included on the booklet that comes with the game that is not in the bundle.

Sparc
09-14-2008, 18:05
God alone knows when this will release in Europe given Rock Band for the PS3 still isn't out here yet. Not sure I can be bothered to wait and may just opt for the GH World Tour instead.

Thorzilla
09-14-2008, 18:08
Rock Band 2 for the ************* win!!!!! Can't wait to pick this up on my PS3. Oh and this is for Thor:

Painkiller - Full Band - 5* (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TRDquEQf99w)

This tops that Screaming for Vengeance video you posted. Skip to the 2 minute mark, they start off with the free song that was up last week. Painkiller>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Anything on GH:WT track list.

:shock: Wham! I want it now!

the_End
09-14-2008, 18:08
No, I don't mean the normal dlc. If you get Rockband 2 they will give you a special code inside on the back of the manual that will let you download 20 dlc songs for free. I'm just wondering if it will also be included on the booklet that comes with the game that is not in the bundle.

I didn't know there was a special code. The stand alone should have it as well because the game in the bundle is the same. It would be pretty damn stupid of Harmonix not to.

Chesser19
09-14-2008, 23:05
Can't wait to get this for my PS3. I'm dying to play the new GN'R song. They should have released the game on all consoles at the same time instead of making us PS3 owners suffer.:lol:

the_End
09-15-2008, 00:51
Can't wait to get this for my PS3. I'm dying to play the new GN'R song. They should have released the game on all consoles at the same time instead of making us PS3 owners suffer.:lol:

Don't worry, the Guns N' Roses song songs major ***. I saw it on youtube and ugh.

Chesser19
09-15-2008, 04:06
I actually heard the song and i'm impressed with it. Now I know it's not like the old songs but at least Axl is still making music (even if it takes him forever) that kicks ***.

Now to get back on topic, I was checking out more videos of gameplay and I must say this game will be a definite buy for me. There's a lot of songs on this game that I really like and the note charts look extremely fun to play.

the_End
09-15-2008, 12:39
I actually heard the song and i'm impressed with it. Now I know it's not like the old songs but at least Axl is still making music (even if it takes him forever) that kicks ***.

Now to get back on topic, I was checking out more videos of gameplay and I must say this game will be a definite buy for me. There's a lot of songs on this game that I really like and the note charts look extremely fun to play.

Except for the last like 5 songs and there solos. Peace Sells has: little beginning solo, little middle solo, actual solo, near ending solo and ending solo. Only three that are in the blue solo areas are the actual solo, near ending solo and ending solo because of there length. Like..... god damn. It's a 4 minute song and most of it is solos.... like damn :lol:.

boogernose
09-15-2008, 15:27
Hmm.. definitely getting RB2 but I'll skip the Painkiller song. I don't enjoy playing (or listening) to the heavy-heavy stuff and neither does anyone else I know! I bought the thrash metal pack (or whatever they call it) and regretted it. The "All That Remains" pack was the first RB DLC that I didn't buy!

Lunar_Chaos
09-15-2008, 15:43
I'm not getting the set but I do plan on getting the game. I wonder if the game alone will still have the 20 bonus dlc songs for free.

Where did you hear this at? :confused: