Sig Battle: Tribunal Vs. Xelis: Round 2 - I owned Tribunal! Mwuaha!

**Xelis** · 03-30-2008

Rules: Excluding The Background Layer, Text, Border and Adjustment layers, make a sig with no more than 10 layers. Provide .psds for proof.

Xelis - 9

.PSD

Tribunal - 7

.PSD

**SteelSamurai** · 03-30-2008

My vote goes to Xelis on this one, but just by a margin invisibly small (we're talking micro meters here

)
Not only do I love Bleach, but the sig has a great feel/atmosphere to it. I still love yours as well though, Tribunal!

**Tribunal** · 03-30-2008

ah-hahahaha, ah-hahahahaha

Didn't see that coming.

**Xelis** · 03-30-2008

Originally Posted by Tribunal

ah-hahahaha, ah-hahahahaha

Didn't see that coming.

Whats that?
[25 Characters]

**MDN** · 03-30-2008

Both are A grade sigs but I'm gonna have to go with Xelis on this one.

**SymphonyX** · 03-30-2008

I like Xelis just a tiny spec more. They are both awesome but Xelis just looks a little bit better.

**TH3 GAM3** · 03-30-2008

I'm going for Xelix on this one.

**furby** · 03-30-2008

I don't know, it looks like Xelis's has too much contrast. I'm gonna go with Tribunal on this one.

**Tribunal** · 03-30-2008

Originally Posted by Xelis

Whats that?
[25 Characters]

You've never been one for good lighting in your signature. This is just a big surprise that you did so well with it with so few layers.

**MiNiMaL_sAnItY** · 03-30-2008

Gonna go with xelis. Trib dude, never put the main focus of your sig in the centre, rule of thirds, rule of thirds....

**Shadowfyre** · 03-30-2008

Xelis's signature looks better to me, though Tribunal's does look great as well.

**Xelis** · 03-30-2008

Originally Posted by Tribunal

You've never been one for good lighting in your signature. This is just a big surprise that you did so well with it with so few layers.

Ironically, its your tutorial that helped me with that, I forgot all about Lighting Effect. So thanks alot for that.

**Tribunal** · 03-30-2008

Yeah I figured if I posted the tutorial you might of used it.

Sal good, though.

Kinda wish that I wasn't the only one getting battled though.

**Xelis** · 03-30-2008

Originally Posted by Tribunal

Yeah I figured if I posted the tutorial you might of used it.

Sal good, though.

Kinda wish that I wasn't the only one getting battled though.

Yeah would be nice to see others having some battles, maybe we could set up a thread seeing whos willing to battle and group people against each other based on their photoshop levels.

**Tribunal** · 03-30-2008

Let me find that son of a bitch.

**hateradio** · 03-30-2008

Originally Posted by MiNiMaL_sAnItY

Gonna go with xelis. Trib dude, never put the main focus of your sig in the centre, rule of thirds, rule of thirds....

rules are supposed to be broken :P but i'll vote for Xelis, because I think the whole thing works together better, though both sigs have horrible typography xD in fact i don't think Xelis' needs text, but maybe it would have looked better on the right ...idk, in any case +1 Xelis

**Xelis** · 03-30-2008

Originally Posted by Tribunal

Let me find that son of a bitch.

Am I missing something here?

Btw were rambling on a bit here

Originally Posted by hateradio

rules are supposed to be broken :P but i'll vote for Xelis, because I think the whole thing works together better, though both sigs have horrible typography xD in fact i don't think Xelis' needs text, but maybe it would have looked better on the right ...idk, in any case +1 Xelis

I freaking hate text cause I suck at it hard, thats one of the next areas Im looking to improve.

**Blacksite** · 03-30-2008

Tribunal takes the cake on this one. My vote would have gone to Xelis, but it's just too busy for my tastes.

**Formula** · 03-30-2008

Yeah, nothing against this one, but BlackSite is so right. Xelis is wayyy too bussy, and everything is almost to dark where you cant see anything. This was one of my least favorite sigs Xelis made. Everythings scattered and the background and colors doesnt really fit with that anime dude at all. I know Xelis is going to pop this one. Trib has mine. It nicely blends in with everything and the coloring isnt to bad. Thats tribs style i guess.

There should be other people who have sig battles, not just tribunal and xelis, because i know there are other really good PS users. So yall should make an Official thread or something. But good work both of you.

**carocat** · 03-31-2008

I'm going with Tribunal. I simply love the background!

But alas it seems I was too late?

**Nuvian** · 03-31-2008

im going with xelis this time,last time it was trib

both are very nice,but xelis's one has that little extra

**Tribunal** · 03-31-2008

Originally Posted by carocat

I'm going with Tribunal. I simply love the background!

But alas it seems I was too late?

You're vote is the only one that matters, so I consider this a victory... even though I'm fairly confident you've back stabbed twice.

**RxForPain** · 03-31-2008

Trib for the win. I think Xelis' is too sharp.

**carocat** · 03-31-2008

Originally Posted by Tribunal

You're vote is the only one that matters, so I consider this a victory... even though I'm fairly confident you've back stabbed twice.

Backstabbed? Me? Never! Ivote for the sig, not the person who created it.

But seriously this BioShock sig is amazing, I've fallen in love with it..

**joeold** · 03-31-2008

If I had to choose I would go with Xelis.

I don't like knowing who made the sig. Its almost reminds me too much of brand loyalty. No offense to either of you I do think you guys do amazing work. I just remember back when you would put up a poll, show just the sigs and then call it a day.