Hopefully he'll be able to get some new shoes made by the exploited children of South America... that'd make me feel much better.
Latest PSU headlines:
Results 4,201 to 4,225 of 4505
-
03-29-2011 #4201
-
03-29-2011 #4202
Don't forget to buy Sony's new handheld i hear it will be made by children too
Good "night" my baby...i will always remember you.I love you.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHZ2cooseqU&annotation_id=annotation_93283 5&feature=iv
-
03-29-2011 #4203
-
03-29-2011 #4204
-
03-29-2011 #4205
-
03-29-2011 #4206
Lol fear and arif that was a good read
-
03-29-2011 #4207
-
03-29-2011 #4208
-
03-29-2011 #4209
-
03-29-2011 #4210
-
03-30-2011 #4211
-
03-30-2011 #4212Forum Sage







- Join Date
- Apr 2006
- Age
- 30
- Posts
- 7,910
- Rep Power
- 88
- Points
- 6,315 (0 Banked)
-
03-30-2011 #4213
-
03-30-2011 #4214
-
03-30-2011 #4215Ultimate Veteran







- Join Date
- Nov 2007
- Location
- Texas
- Posts
- 20,217
- Rep Power
- 127
- Points
- 74,705 (0 Banked)
Last edited by radgamer420; 03-30-2011 at 06:20.
-
03-30-2011 #4216
-
03-30-2011 #4217
-
03-30-2011 #4218Sublimely Static







- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Vekta
- Age
- 30
- Posts
- 10,024
- Rep Power
- 95
- Points
- 17,352 (0 Banked)
Well, let me do my best armchair lawyer summation of the accounts. Keep in mind I am sure I have done this before in the case and it turned out as expected.
Sony isn't going after him for violating the TOS, Simply are trying to prove he was aware of their existence. There is precedence for damage done against a company to have the jurisdiction around the HQ of said company.It is also worth noting that SCEA has failed to proffer any PSN TOS that could be applicable to Mr. Hotz, even assuming everything SCEA has said is true, because the PSN TOS SCEA has proffered was created after Mr. Hotz purportedly created a PSN account.
Which is false. Only the first 11 Digits are the serial number and they are trying to argue descrepencies between part numbers. It is still from the same machine.Now, SCEA claims that Mr. Hotz must have created a PSN account for the name “blickmaniac” because the serial number of one of the Playstation Computers that Mr. Hotz purchased-- including 3 Playstation Computers that were purchased used-- was used to register a PSN account. The serial number utilized by SCEA, however, is different from the serial number proffered by Mr. Hotz's attorney
1. SCEA "was" the legal representation for SCE in America and a subsidiary. Period. This has been known for many years and constantly put to the test. The PS2 DRE lawsuits were handled by SCEA not SCE. SCEA is responsible for the marketing and distribution of Playstation consoles (PSP, PS2, PS3 and soon to be NGP) in canada, US and latin america. It is false and misleading to try to claim they only deal with the games. SCE doesn't behave as an entity in any of these countries, they are always legally represented by the subsidiaries.To be clear, Sony Japan-- not SCEA-- is responsible for manufacturing, distributing, and marketing the Playstation Computer. Sony Japan is the owner of all rights, title, and interest in, to and under the copyrights in the PS3 Programmer Tools, although SCEA misleadingly lists this information under the heading “SCEA's Copyrights and Copyright Licenses”. Complaint, ¶30. On the other hand, SCEA, which is not even a subsidiary of Sony Japan, focuses on the sales of products and video games. Complaint, ¶22. SCEA develops, markets and distributes video games, and speaks extensively about video games in its pleadings. Opposition, p2. However, Mr. Hotz' actions have nothing to do with video games and the Code does not provide users the ability to run pirated video games or any other pirated software, as SCEA claims. Opposition, p2.
Presumably, had one of Sony Japan's hundreds of affiliates initiated a lawsuit in a different forum, such affiliate would modify the discourse to argue that Hotz focused on music (e.g., Sony Music Entertainment, Inc.), movies (e.g., Sony Pictures Classics, Inc.), electric components (e.g., Sony Corporation, Inc.), or some other aspect tangentially related to the Playstation Computer in an attempt to confer jurisdiction in such forum. The Playstation Computer provides for many functions-- in fact, it's slogan is that “It Only Does Everything”. The fact that Mr. Hotz purportedly impacted the Playstation Computer does not mean that all of these affiliates, including component manufacturers in China, can suddenly claim that Mr. Hotz directed his activities toward them.
When one purchases a Playstation Computer and looks at its outer box, it has plastered on numerous places that it is a product of Sony Japan and all rights belong to Sony Japan. It only references Sony Japan-- not SCEA. When one takes the Playstation Computer out of its box and inspects it, it states it is a product of Sony Japan and all rights belong to Sony Japan. It does not reference California. When one installs the Playstation Computer firmware update that Mr. Hotz allegedly circumvented, which can legally be obtained through the internet as Mr. Hotz did, upon installation, it only refers to Sony Japan.
2. The quote in question Hotz' lawyer is trying to put through mental gymnastics is
At first they want to make a big deal out of SCEA omitting the any of you three part. It doesn't matter if it is there or not, the three can logically be construed as MS, Nintendo and Sony, The comment is still directed at sony, the fact that he also directed it at two other companies is irrelevant to this case. Also "if you want your next console" basically locks it down to a very specific division of sony. That would be SCE in general and in turn involves any subsidiary in charge of that locale.“If you want your next console to be secure, contact me, any of you three.”
3. The box and documents state SCE, which is an all encomassing term for SCEJ/SCEasia, SCEE and SCEA. They use that terminology because products and games can be used interchangeably between divisions so an all encompassing term for the branches suit best.
4. You have to ask the court to file something under seal. Sony filed under seal after the motions were granted by the court. If the files being sealed somehow hindered the courts ability "to do its work" I doubt they would have granted it.
Groklaw has been terribly suspect with the presentation of this case especially with the side commentary that is either inane or simply false. Going everywhere from talking about Sony BMG and bringing up PlayStation Suite as if it has any relevance. If I was only to follow and believe groklaw I would be continuously stunned and amazed at how much Sony has defeated over the OtherOS case and the actions granted in the Hotz case. Because instead of looking at the facts straight, the amount of spin Groklaw has put on this, makes sony's court achievements seem miraculous. To me, this type of spin only seems prevalent in those trying to defend hotz as if this case is symbolic of something greater. It isn't.
Hacking won't ever stop. Homebrew and piracy will not stop. And Hotz winning won't bring positive things to the table. People honestly think that Sony wouldn't adapt to what went wrong and try something even more horribly restrictive but legally sound? There is no win for any real gamers supporting Hotz and there is no win for homebrew supporters either.
-
03-30-2011 #4219
I disagree with your assessment of it, and agree with what I posted. So again, we'll see.
-
03-30-2011 #4220
-
03-30-2011 #4221Banned







- Join Date
- Jan 2011
- Posts
- 358
- Rep Power
- 0
- Points
- 2,767 (0 Banked)
you guys are still going on about geohotz the things moved on oh yeah Graf another ps3 dev whos trying to bring back linux got $28,000 in donations for ps3 legal defence fund lols in under a week
-
03-30-2011 #4222
-
03-30-2011 #4223
-
03-30-2011 #4224
If it has a firmware update, it'll tell you before the game launches.
-
03-30-2011 #4225
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)




Reply With Quote







Bookmarks