http://www.joystiq.com/2011/08/08/fr...kinect-review/It is good to chop fruit with your hands.
That's likely to be my very dumbest thesis for the remainder of my games-reviewing career, but let's face it: Fruit Ninja Kinect is an astonishingly dumb game. Its unswerving singlemindedness sets a new standard for simplicity: The game oscillates between binary states of chopping fruit and waiting to chop more fruit, with little extraneous cruft to pad the two. There is fruit, and then you chop it, and then the fruit -- in a burst of citrus and points -- is gone!
Such a single-faceted premise would be a mark of death for any game, even a budget-priced downloadable title. Luckily for Halfbrick, it is good to chop fruit with your hands.
Fruit Ninja Kinect (6/7/11)
If you're familiar of the mobile version of the produce-hostile casual title, you already know everything there is to know about this winning formula. As fruit is launched upward by an unseen assailant, players must slash each foodstuff before it falls out of sight. Bonus points are earned for destroying multiple vittles in a single slash, requiring a certain level of quiet contemplation as you flail about like the world's worst ground air traffic controller.
Oh, the flailing you'll do. The substitution of swift flicks of your fingertips with decisive thrusts of your entire upper body easily justifies the ten-times-more-expensive price of the XBLA title over the app. There is a level of satisfaction one achieves when performing a rising uppercut on a cluster of tightly-grouped watermelons that cannot be matched -- or even approached -- by a game that only requires you to move half of one percent of your body.
You'll execute these precise cuts across a myriad of game modes, most of which were imported from the smartphone-based original. Classic Mode tasks you with scoring as many points as possible before you drop three fruit, or chop one of the frequently launched, game-ending bombs. Arcade is set to a timer, and throws special bonuses into the mix, like fruit-freezing and score-multiplying bananas. Zen mode offers a much more straightforward, 90-second free-for-all.
New to the assortment is a two-player mode, which can either be played competitively -- fruits are highlighted red or blue, and can only be chopped by the corresponding player -- or cooperatively. The Kinect hasn't provided too many moments of raw happiness more pure than when I stood shoulder-to-shoulder with my fellow fruit chopper, slicing through panic-inducing swarms of produce, all the while trying not to deliver a fatal hatchet blow directly to my companion's real-life face.
There's also a Challenge mode that shows up on the very front menu of the game, which allows you to immediately go after the higher score of one of your Xbox Live Friends. This was, invariably, the first thing I did every time I booted up Fruit Ninja Kinect -- to think that someone, somewhere, had bested my score on Classic mode was always an unacceptable truth, and one that required instant remedy.
There are some really great ideas in here for other Kinect developers to study: For instance, getting yourself into prime fruit-cutting position is a breeze by merit of the fact that your shadow is constantly displayed on screen. Also, if you walk too close or too far from the sensor, the game automatically calibrates within seconds, centering the game's field of view at the optimal slicing height. There is no reason why every game on the platform shouldn't do these two things.
The only bit of clunk which surfaces as a result of the new hands-free control scheme is the menu UI, which sees your every movement as an eager chop towards whatever menu option your hand is closest to. You can eventually learn to temper your movements to cut back on these false positives -- though attempting to swipe through the game's lengthy list of unlockable blades, backgrounds and shadows is an exercise in blinding frustration.
Perhaps it was unfair to call Fruit Ninja Kinect dumb. Its premise is as barbaric and unsophisticated as premises come, and yet its so chock-full of clever ideas and satisfyingly tight controls that it very nearly circles back around to pure genius. It doesn't just set a high bar for the flock of touch-based apps which will almost certainly follow in its footsteps to the Kinect platform -- it sets a pretty intimidating precedent for the platform altogether.
I added this to my queue and will give it a spin.
Results 1 to 19 of 19
08-10-2011 #1Soldier 95BGuest
Fruit Ninja Kinect review: The joy of chopping
I may have to give this a try. I didn't think it would turn out to be any good.
i let all my nieces and nephews. they love it best game ever
Consoles i own : ps2 xbox360 Ps3 Wii psp
Wanna see what i look like www.facebook.com/laoman
08-14-2011 #4Soldier 95BGuest
Gave the demo a try. Not for me. It wasn't for me on mobile platform either.
03-06-2012 #6Soldier 95BGuest
Last edited by mistercrow; 03-06-2012 at 17:51.
My point is just this Rad...
say Coke comes out with Diet Cherry Coke.. are they now focusing on SOLEY that product and will let Coke slip down and not advertise it, support it? Are they now focusing on the diet crowd and forsaking the people who like coke?
Same thing with this, which is why i take issue with the derogatory way in which people say "shift in focus".. they didn't shift focus, they added a new branch to their product line.
Nothing is being taken away from the old, only the new business for the Kinect is being done. We are going to get the games that would have come out if Kinect hadn't come to light.
But you're right, it has been gone over before, so I will just drop it.Imagine something witty here
Sub-stance1 likes this post
03-06-2012 #12Soldier 95BGuest
- Join Date
- Feb 2008
- South Carolina
- PSN ID
- Rep Power
I don't see the issue with you discussing it CUGY, especially if it KEEPS getting brought up.
I happen to agree that they've shifted more focus towards casual gaming of late, and allowed their 3rd party lineup to add that core experience to the few titles they MGS will release.
03-06-2012 #15Soldier 95BGuest
Over the past couple days I have posted new threads that continue to debunk that myth. If people think the 360 shifted focus to casual, we might as well say the PS has as well. Both statements, IMO, are ludicrous.
Last edited by mistercrow; 03-07-2012 at 00:08.
03-07-2012 #19Soldier 95BGuest
MS has done the same. If you don't agree in your opinion, it's not a big deal.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)