NCAA Football 09 Review

  • Posted July 14th, 2008 at 23:36 EDT by
  • 9,367 views
  • 9 Comments

Review Score

NCAA Football 09

PSU Review Score
7.5
Avg. user review score:
6.7

Add your rating

Summary

NCAA 2009 is a step above its previous installment and shows EA Sports is dedicated to improving the brand name they’ve created.

We like

  • Online Dynasty is fantastic
  • Custom Stadium Sounds system is innovative
  • Atmosphere is dead on

We dislike

  • Shimmy can toy with the AI
  • Broken defensive zones
  • Player vs. player experience

See PSU's review on Metacritic & GameRankings

(continued from previous page) ...what Campus Legend is, it allows you to create-a-player or utilize an existing one in order to play that one and only position. It’s kind of like the 5 vs 5 mode in FIFA, except you’re able to progress through an entire collegiate career as that one player.

The mode starts you off going through your local High School state tournament in hopes of turning the heads of certain scouts and landing a great scholarship opportunity at the University of your choosing. The stats you compile during this tournament not only affect your overall attributes, but they will also play a large role into what place on the depth chart you’ll be offered. If you want to start right away, you may have to go to a lower ranked team, while if you want to just play for your favorite school, you’ll probably have to work your way up the roster.

In order to work your way up to the starting role, you’ll be given the chance to partake in daily practices that will allow you to earn points in order to climb the ladder. Once you’ve earned the required point total, you’ll move up to the next spot in the depth chart. Not only will practice give you the ability to do this, but it will also allow you to gain permanent attribute increases to your player. If practice isn’t your thing, you can participate in many night events in order to gain temporary increases in attributes. These night events will range from hitting the library, working out at the gym, studying your playbook and visiting your training. Don’t ever forget though that if you allow your GPA to hit below a 2.0 (C average), you’ll be suspended from athletic participation, so be sure to hit the library whenever needed to gain a boost in GPA. One of the problems that arose from this was it seemed way too easy to have your stats boost and maintain a healthy GPA. These boosts come into play at an alarmingly unrealistic rate.

From this point, you’ll play through games just like your default Dynasty Mode and earn legendary status throughout your campus depending on how well your player plays. Hopefully you have a successful enough collegiate career that you’ll be drafted in the NFL someday and start making the real virtual dollars that matter.

Mini-Games:

The mini-games section has also received some new implementations that will help you hone your skills a bit quicker. These two new additions are Horse and Special Teams Challenge.

Horse is a field goal kicking competition that allows you to place the ball at any point on the field and attempt the kick. If successful, your opponent must match your attempt. However, if your opponent misses, he will be given a letter. It's the Horse you know and love.



As for the Special Teams Challenge, it works much like Tug-of-War except utilizing the punt teams instead. Users must gain better field advantage through their returns in hopes of reaching field goal range or returning a kick all the way to the house. Once either of those goals is achieved, the winner is decided and the game ends. The mini-games section still offers up the classic Option Dash, Tug-of-War and Bowling for the veterans of the franchise.

Gameplay:

This is where the game seemed to have the potential to not only shine but also separate itself from the game released last year. For some odd reason the game plays extremely differently when you compare playing against the computer to playing against an actual human opponent. NCAA 2009 has been revamped with an entirely new engine of play and level of responsiveness, but it doesn't necessarily show as much as it should.

Some of the newer features provided are Ice the Kicker and QB Composure Quiz. Both of these add a nice element of play to the title and definitely can make things interesting. Calling a timeout in a key situation during a field goal attempt will enact the Ice the Kicker scenario. This will create a low-angle camera view that makes it difficult to aim the kick. On top of this, the kicking meter will appear iced over and be much harder to read in ... (continued on next page)

Advertisement

Comments

Comment

What are your thoughts?

  1. bplewis24

    • 12:01am BST - July 15th, 2008

    Thanks for the review.  This answered several questions I had.

     

    Brandon

  2. chumdiddy | DanWillHor

    • 1:38am BST - July 15th, 2008

    Just got the game at midnight and while its not perfect, its LIGHTYEARS better than NCAA 2008!!!

     

    Good review but I would actually give it an 8 or 8.5

     

     

  3. funItalian

    • 7:38am BST - July 15th, 2008

    sounds like NCAA 09 has great graphics and an overall feel of what collegiate football should be and the review helped a lot, but I just can't help but to think the player v.s. player game play is not up to par. Without great gameplay the game itself is not worth the $60 purchase in my humble opinion. Maybe I'll rent it first just to see if it's worth the money.

  4. mcwups1

    • 11:15am BST - July 15th, 2008

    "Dynasty Mode:

    Dynasty Mode has always been the backbone of the NCAA franchise, offering users the opportunity to lead a college program to national dominance. The mode gives the player the responsibilities of red-shirting players, creating recruitment boards, setting depth charts, customizing your schedule and even inviting future prospects to watch your team play."

    You mean, like a coach would?  Huh?  Too bad you can't really "coach"....you have to actually "user-control" the players, which defeats the purpose behind "Dynasty Mode" to begin with.  Yeah....real good job EA.  Just sit back on your lazy butts, add a little something, and collect all that money from people who don't care about quality.  I might rent it, just to see if they actually took Josh Portis off of the "Transfer" status, after being at Maryland for 3 years now.  Nah....I won't.

  5. I95SOUTH | I95SOUTH

    • 1:19pm BST - July 15th, 2008

    I play NCAA football every year. You have to know whats its about. its not just a football game. I played football for 18 years and I have to say EA does a great job with the NCAA games each year bring something great with it. Im sorry but the rate it should never go under a 8.5 even with last years game being the worst one made atleast an 8.

     

    psn id: I95SOUTH

  6. VictorValiant

    • 2:53am BST - July 16th, 2008

    Gameplay can be tweaked with the sliders and there may be some major bugs with the sliders, such as assigning the wrong attribute to a slider.  This is being investigated by some gamers at another site's forum.  I'm not sure about this website's policy on linking to another forum, so if it's ok, I can do that.

  7. Jaxnole22

    • 3:36pm BST - July 17th, 2008

    I always get the game- it has changed.

    Here's a question- i own ps2- why do i have to "add" every player and number to both dynasty roster/ and the fbs just to play other people and points pursuit etc? am i missing somthing, like add roster to fbs and it when i pick dynasty it adds the corrected players?

  8. I95SOUTH | I95SOUTH

    • 2:12pm BST - July 18th, 2008

    Im sorry but this is the best one they ever made. I have played all of thm since 96 and nobody can tell me anything about playing NCAA Football. EA, you did it with this one. 10 out 10!!

     

    psn id: I95SOUTH

  9. TreNazT

    • 3:06pm GMT - March 1st, 2009

    does anyone have the rooster that I can download onto a memory stick ?

     

Related information

  • Related game: NCAA Football 09

    Release date (US):
    July 15th, 2008
    Developer:
    Tiburon
    Genre:
    Sports - American Football
    Rank:
    110 of 1,470 Games
    Up 0 places (in last 7 days)

Related images

eXTReMe Tracker