Mirror's Edge Review
- Posted December 2nd, 2008 at 07:47 EDT by Steven Williamson
- 9,160 views
- 40 Comments
Review Score
- PSU Review Score
- 6.5
- Avg. user review score:
- 6.9
Summary
Mirror's Edge is both unique and stimulating, but it rapidly loses momentum after a great start.
We like
- Visually stimulating
- Simple, but fun to execute free-running moves
We dislike
- Combat is useless
- Enemies constantly on your tail gets annoying
- Interior locations - bland level design
See PSU's review on Metacritic & GameRankings
By using the increasingly popular free-running activity of Parkour as its theme and mixing it with a story of murder and intrigue, EA’s DICE Studio certainly deserves credit for thinking outside of the conventional box. Despite some thrills along the way though it’s an experiment that ultimately fails to provide the exhilarating and free-flowing first person action experience that we’d hoped. Mirror’s Edge is a great concept that starts off well, but doesn’t quite live up to its full potential and dazzling good looks.
By giving you control over a range of intuitive and fun-to-execute acrobatic free-running moves, Mirror’s Edge shows great promise in the initial stages as you vault impressively over fences, scale buildings, shimmy up drainpipes and make huge leaps of faith across rooftops in an attempt to smoothly traverse the sparkling and stylishly designed metropolis. However, during the first half-an-hour or so of springing, sliding and jumping across the environment you’ll have experienced practically everything, certainly all the good things anyway, that the game has to offer. The fast pace, the feeling of speed and the flowing movement of free-running that is so accurately captured in the preliminary levels also fails to filter into the latter parts of the game where the action slows down considerably before grinding to an abrupt halt at its unsatisfactory conclusion, a measly 5 to 6 hours later.
Set within the confines of a totalitarian regime, where all forms of communication are strictly monitored by the powers that be, the story of Mirror’s Edge follows Faith, a free-running courier who spends her days working above the law sprinting across the city, dodging government officials along the way in order to deliver sensitive data to a group of revolutionaries. It’s a story-line that had great potential, but even with the nicely drawn anime cut-scenes that accompany each chapter, yet never quite live up to the quality of the gorgeous in-game graphics, it soon dies its death and becomes nothing more than an irrelevant distraction and an excuse to just run around the city dodging gun-wielding officials.
When you first find yourself standing upon a rooftop high above the busy city streets, where you get a first glimpse at the massive concrete jungle of mirrored-glass-encrusted skyscrapers and brilliant white rooftops far away in the distance, it’s an impressive sight. The city looks encouragingly huge, an adventure playground for free-runners, so you’d think. However, despite a few branching paths, Mirror’s Edge is a disappointingly linear game where pathways to your goal are indicated via “Runner Vision,” red objects that highlight where you can safely jump to reach a balcony or rooftop, where you can climb up a set of ladders, grab onto a drain-pipe or scurry through a ventilation shaft.
The inside locations in particular are very restricted with set paths to follow restricting you to grabbing only onto certain ledges or smashing through particular doors. The outside locations, however, do offer a certain degree of freedom and at least allow you to make the most of the set of acrobatic moves on offer. Once you string a few actions together, which requires inch perfect timing, the feeling of speed and movement as you dive under ducts, spring into the air from ledge to ledge or zip-line from one roof-top to the next, makes for an exciting experience.
Part of the excitement is because the developer has created a sense of urgency throughout the game. You constantly have to keep on the move wherever you go at all times otherwise you get caught in a storm of bullets from government officials who burst onto rooftops and surround you at any given opportunity. Initially, this keeps the game moving and flowing and encourages you to take risks that see you taking on big jumps, which occasionally won’t pay off. However, it also works to the detriment of the gameplay and at times you’re pushed a bit too hard; you're just not given enough time to think. If you stop for a moment to look around in order to work out where you need to go you’ll more often than not get shot. Especially later on in the game, when pathway hints become fewer, this means that ... (continued on next page)
- Page 1
- Page 2
Comments
-
Fijiandoce |
Fijiandoce- 7:54am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 1
6.5....i loved this game. hehehe oh well players opinion :)
-
-
-
-
hesmanes |
hesmanes- 8:53am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 5
@ 2 you can use bullet time to slow everything down for a about 5 secs to combat against those pesky kids! i mean the Law. i have the game and im enjoying it though it was abit silly of me because i bought COD5, Mirrors Edge, and LBP at the same time, and im having to juggle all of them! I'll remember next time to just stick with one at a time!
-
The_Hells_Angels |
The_Hells_Angels- 9:14am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 6
All you see in this gmes is WHITE,BLUE AND RED. the graphic is really good but do you really think that thats the only colors we have in every city? the whole concept and idea of the game is nice since we didt see anything really like this before but the fighting and the combat in this game is really useless,just jump and jump and jump and thats it. maybe mirrors edge 2 will make it better.
-
GunTeng
- 9:42am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 7
Sad to hear the game turned out like this.
Maybe there will be another installement where they can treat this one as a prologue. The next one they have allow a varied pace, by creating a stealth ability....I mean, how do the authorities always know where she is? Where are the CCTV cameras, search parties etc? Could she not percievably use stealth to pass these by & when caught, sends a pille of officials your way causing you to get a move on? Think on something similar to the MGS games.
Being careful gets you time to think & explore, while being spotted causes the pace to pick up & the dodgng to begin.
And where are the varied objectives? People need a reason to be doing something....and it would seem, too little thought was put into this. Running becuase you are being hunted is one thing, but there has to be an objective other than escaping. What about spying to get to the truth? Make use of the fact of having to enter buildings by having to sneak into govt. offices from the rooftops etc.
Oh well.
I thought the story would be the downfall of this game & it would seem I was right. There just isnt enough to fill out what could have been a great game. They had some things perfect ( movement.visuals)...and yet it seems it was still too linear.
Maybe next time.
All I can say is DICE, don't give up. Make another one with these things in mind...bigger & better. Add puzzle elements into it...like moving a crane to be able to get onto another area etc....theres so much you could do.
-
Staticneuron |
Staticneuron- 9:48am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 8
Thats because the glowing weapon thing is useless. Spend a few seconds to learn the timing of disarming each particular weapon, and then you are gold. Spend a couple minutes more and you can find a combat combo that takes enemies down faster than the disarm.
All it would have taken was a little bit of experimentation because this games holds you by the hand less and less as you prgress further in the game.
Combat is far from useless because it helps you take on larger groups of enemies once you get combo's down. Unless you like dieing alot, trying to run past enemies or disarm them one at a time at the later part of the game, must be horribly tedious if you have not gotten down the basics of the combo's down.
If the pace of the game slows to a crawl then blame no one other than yourself.
@GunTeng, don't take this review to heart like that. Trust me, things were explained in the game and there were minor puzzle elements to it. You are judging the game on what you "feel" it should be. Why don't you rent the game to experienced what it actually is about before you build up those preconcieved notions of yours.
I am not going to drop spoilers here for those that have not played the game, I will just say that this is a simple story about a regular person caught in a grand situation. Mirrors edge is finally one of those games where it is ok just o be a person, instead of a superhero/villian/fighter for justice and all that nonsense. Games do not always have to surround extrodinary people, and that is what puts them in line with films. If you believe that games always require overblown stories than you must not think much about the medium.
-
DantheMan_69
- 10:40am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 9
This game is gr8 it's something new aswell it's a 9 not 6.5 and combat ain't useless u lot just don't know how to play. mirrors edge is worth playing 9/10.
-
-
-
Gomersoul |
Gomersoul- 11:16am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 12
i liked this game, it is just far too short. very good idea, i don't think combat was the aim of this game anyway, you can complete it without shooting anyone. the story of the city and the runners is good, but thought it could of been done better. the levels are a bit plain but it's good to see a game that isn't covered in brown/grey colours like most are. at least it's a fresh idea, not just another shooter 8/10 for me
-
mmntech
- 11:43am GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 13
I think the game deserves at least a 7.5 though I do agree it can be frustrating at times. R2 as the fire button is what really threw me off in combat since it's R1 in a lot of other games. I liked the game though. It may not be the best title of 2008 but it's still pretty decent overall.
-
-
-
-
Funeralfog |
blksabbath- 12:37pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 17
i love the game, a nice clean setting and unless you're colorblind its easy to spot the red. i like the fact that combat is a last resort. why doesnt anyone want SOMETHING DIFFERENT. this is the only game thats different available to buy
-
-
-
-
-
IceShade |
Ice_Shade- 2:35pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 22
Whoever reviewed this game must not be very good at playing it. The visuals are great! I quite literally jumped out of my chair on the train level. This game is beautiful. Yes, you can beat the game without doing very much combat, but the system is actually rather fun and it's continually entertaining to find the fastest method of taking down enemies in your way. Having enemies constantly on your tail is exciting unless, again, you are really bad at this game and can't figure out how to get away. The time trials, speed runs, and hidden bags give it a great amount of replay value. This is my third favorite game I own on the PS3, behind (1) Metal Gear Solid 4 and (2) Call of Duty 4. I give it a 9.
-
hvnlyswrd08
- 4:22pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 23
Wut the F@#$!!! I hate PSUs reviews, first Tomb Raider and now this... this game deffinetly deserves more than a 6.5..how the heck can combat be useless idiot..and the whole point is to runaway wich is why the cops are always tailing you duh..a little advice: you should just stop writting reviews, you suk at them....make all the good games sound like sh!t
-
Girugamesh |
Shidousha- 5:17pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 24
PSU, you realize that just because a lot of games are getting good reviews does NOT mean you have to make a game unjustly review a low score just so they do not all get high scores?
This is a ridiculous score for the game, pretty unjust in the least.
-
-
-
Strudel |
Strudel- 6:53pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 27
I really enjoyed this game, the story was ok but the first person perspective of a free runner is great. true the fighting and shooting feels underpowered but it's suposed too, this is all about free running. Sounds boring, but there's nothing quite like geting a great combo together where you get yourself somewhere you didn't think possible.
Now that I've completed it I don't feel like playing it again, but then again I do have a few unopened games sitting on my desk waiting to be played once I've finished the ones I'm currently playing, gotta love the xmas rush of games!
-
AnalogueAutomat |
AnalogueAutomat- 7:15pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 28
i thought you needed to be a gamer to write reviews on this site...
-
Blaze463 |
Blaze463- 7:47pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 29
To everyone bashing this review and praising the game: Just because the game is "different", it does not automatically mean it's good. It's a fps without guns. watered down. all you do is run around everywhere, the game is boring.
3/10 theres my 2 sentence review lol
-
-
hvnlyswrd08
- 8:54pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 31
@29 thats not what most people praising the game are saying... but the game is different and it is not just that that makes this game really good
-
Arimax
- 9:23pm GMT - December 2nd, 2008
- 32
You know one thing you guys must realize. Games like these aren't really games per say their more like a test. Cause EA is trying to see what else they can do with the FPS perspective in their games. Atleast that's the way I see it. It's not only this game either that other game Heavy Rain is also a testing type of game.
-
-
GunTeng
- 9:16am GMT - December 3rd, 2008
- 34
True Static, I am assuming a lot from what I half expected & from what I was hearing.
I intend buying the game at some stage after Christmas anyhow, so I will find out then. Due to the lack of games this gen that I can fully get into & devote most of my time to, I am left with games I love for their relaxed approach like LBP. I expected to be playing Socom day & night, but without the FPS mode, that is lost to me.
So even if the game is small, it has something fresh...something I could play, put down & play again. But I do think there could have been more to it...ok there may be an odd puzzle element, but does it do enough...thats the question.
I will see soon enough, and yes I am still one of those that would point out the game to people as one to experience...but I still believe it may not have done all it could have, which may leave it feeling lacking.
-
TerraFyin95 |
Terra95- 4:39pm GMT - January 30th, 2009
- 35
i got this game, completed it twice, and its a good game. u neva get bored of it. if ur at home and u cant b bothered to play any other game u plkay mirrors edge. thats wat i do n it keeps me occupied. i rated it a 9
-
Superblaster76
- 4:53pm GMT - February 7th, 2009
- 36
I love this game, in fact this is the only game that I have bought on the PS3 vs. it's 360 counter-part. Bioshock, GTA, Fallout, Half Life all play better on 360 but this one is a bit smoother on PS3. I also bought it on PS3 because besides Little Big Planet and Uncharted and bowling on Home there wasn't anything else I wanted to buy to play on it anyway. Besides blu-ray movies that is. Glad to hear it's a planned trilogy.
-
-
semnus313 |
ls7knightmare- 10:36pm GMT - February 24th, 2009
- 38
I own this game as well and i whole heartedly agree with this review its fun but alot of trial and error to get the timing of it down and tis extremely frustrating but onces its down the game really opens up but then its too short. by the time u master combat and stop getting lost u will have beat it 5 times.even for a trilogy this is a short 1st chapter. i hope 2 is much longer and keeps the controls the same so you dont spend the entire game learning again.kudos on thinking outside the box though id recommend buying a used or discounted version
-
imperator_mundi
- 9:23am BST - July 22nd, 2009
- 39
Visually great. Very compelling control system with a good learning curve. Rather short story mode, and to be completely honest the story didn't really catch me, still I really enjoyed the game.
Enemies and combats are the weakest point of the game, luckily they're of marginal importance.
-
f15airhawk
- 5:38pm BST - September 30th, 2009
- 40
i will never buy a game on its review score ..on its box it was 10/10 ...it was utter waste ..first ill watch trailer then ..watch a gameplay on youtube then ill buy...thanx for teaching me a lesson
Advertisement